Sixteen ounces is the maximum size they make in the shop, seeing as anything else is "so heavy they make your belly feel like it has a cinder block in it. Co-founded by Doug Quint and Bryan Petroff, BGIC specializes in soft-serve ice cream cones, cups, and novelties with a menu of unique and unusual flavors and toppings. Landlords 509 Columbus Properties LLC filed a complaint in May 2021 alleging Big Gay Ice Cream owed nearly 250,000 in unpaid rent, court records show. While you're at it, stick a metal straw in the freezer alongside the cup for ideal sipping. Big Gay Ice Cream (BGIC) is a New York Citybased company that started with an ice cream truck and now operates four storefronts in the city. A New York Supreme Civil Court judge ruled in favor of evicting the ice cream shop owners who do business as Big Gay Agenda LLC on Valentine's Day, Feb. The shake cup itself works just fine, or you can put a pint glass in the freezer for 30 minutes before pouring.
To enhance your milkshake experience, Quint suggests a few simple things. The recipe has just four ingredients-milk, chocolate syrup, chocolate ice cream and smooth peanut butter-but they whir into a soul-satisfying blend that's best paired with a nap. "It's probably the most extreme thing we'll ever do. Not only was the mash-up a success, it went on the menu that day and became Quint's favorite shake at the shop. When one customer kept begging for a chocolate-peanut butter shake, Quint finally relented, telling him, "You have to promise that if you don't like it, you're not going to go on Yelp and bitch about me, because it's an experiment." See restaurant menus, reviews, ratings, phone number, address, hours, photos and maps. BGIC stores stock peanut butter for special requests, but it's generally not on the menu due to allergy concerns. View the menu for Big Gay Ice Cream Shop and restaurants in New York, NY.